ANNOUNCEMENTS

Welcome to the Thirsty Pagan Family.

Welcome to the Thirsty Pagan. We are a small microbrewery and pub located in the historic Russel Creamery building at 1623 Broadway, in Superior, WI.

We are a SMOKE FREE environment 365 days a year! We like it, and since we own it, that's nice.

Please come in and join us for a pint or pizza, or both! We can't wait to see you!

The original Thirsty Pagan brewery

The original location of the Thirsty Pagan Brewery

Brewery History

In May of 2006 Susan and Steve Knauss purchased the existing Twin Ports Brewing Co. This simple sentence gives insight to the simple approach that these two took in producing a wonderful company, Thirsty Pagan Brewing. Building on a firm foundation of pizza and beer, our two entrepreneurs quickly took a down and out location to a thriving destination. "We recognize our potential in focusing on just two things, pizza and beer. Do those two things correctly, and the world will come to us," says Steve Knauss; and obviously, they have.

In February 2011, Gustave Axelson of the New York Times hit the road for a midwestern beer tour of northern Minnesota and Wisconsin. Axelson's tour included a stop at Thirsty Pagan, but you'll have to read the New York Times article to find out the rest.

Just recently, Thirsty Pagan has celebrated their 8th year anniversary. "We continue to fine tune our well oiled machine, and look out for our next great adventure, just around the corner!" What that is, Steve would not elude to... However, with the Pagan's pizza and beer as their foothold on the restaurant community, we can only imagine what these folks may have up their sleeves.

Hours of Operation

Daily Hours

  • Monday-Wednesday |11AM-11PM
  • Thursday-Sunday | 11AM-midnight (or later)

Dining Hours

  • Everyday | 11AM-10PM

Special Events:

    Duluth Superior Pride Parade

  • Beer, Pizza by the Slice, & DJ Nola
  • Date | August 31st
  • Time | 10AM - 2PM
  • Get ready for the parade at the Pagan. We will be open early for parade line up, and offering beer and pizza by the slice out front. DJ Nola will be playing the music. Regular bar and full menu available starting at 11AM.

Live from the Thirsty Pagan Stage

  • Thursday, August 14, 2014
  • 6pm | Fuzzy Ellis
  • Friday, August 15, 2014
  • 5PM | Deja Vu Drifters
  • 8PM | Four Legg Fish
  • Saturday, August 16, 2014
  • 5PM | Haley Lawson
  • 8PM | Andrew Austin
  • Sunday, August 17, 2014
  • 6PM | Joe & Friends
  • 10PM | Open Mic
  • Monday, August 18, 2014
  • 6PM | DJ Nola
  • Tuesday, August 19, 2014
  • 6PM | Chris & Mark and Wild Bill
  • Wednesday, August 20, 2014
  • 6pm | Little Big Band
  • Thursday, August 21, 2014
  • 6pm | Jimi Cooper
  • Friday, August 22, 2014
  • 5PM | Stel & Friends
  • 8PM | The North Electric
  • Saturday, August 23, 2014
  • 5PM | Tim Kirchhof
  • 8PM | Greg Highlands and the Blacklist
  • Sunday, August 24, 2014
  • 6PM | Joe & Friends
  • 10PM | Open Mic
  • Monday, August 25, 2014
  • 6PM | DJ Nola
  • Tuesday, August 26, 2014
  • 6PM | Chris & Mark and Wild Bill
  • Wednesday, August 27, 2014
  • 6pm | Little Big Band
  • Thursday, August 28, 2014
  • 6pm | Jimi Cooper
  • Friday, August 29, 2014
  • 5PM | Bill & Kate Isles
  • 8PM | Phyl Wickham
  • Saturday, August 30, 2014
  • 5PM | Preston Gunderson
  • 8PM | Chris Kemnitz
  • Sunday, August 31, 2014
  • 10AM-Noon | DJ NOLA "SIDEWALK DANCE PARTY"
  • **Join us for the start of the pride parade!**
  • **Beer and Pizza by the slice on our patio!**
  • 6PM | Joe & Friends
  • 10PM | Open Mic
  • Monday, Sept 1, 2014
  • 6PM | DJ Nola

* Subject to change

For booking email benb@thirstypaganbrewing.com

How do I find the Thirsty Pagan?

Get driving directions here:

Thirsty Pagan Brewing
1623 Broadway
Superior, WI 54880
715.394.2500

The Thirsty Pagan Delivers Pizza for Lunch!

The next time you are having a meeting or a big wig comes to town, call the brewery 715-394-2500. Thirsty Pagan now DELIVERS pizza from 11:00 AM to 1:00 PM for businesses.

If your staff is looking for something new to try, or, if someone has been raving about the great pizza at the Thirsty Pagan, here is the chance to see what it's all about! Currently, Thirsty Pagan only delivers to businesses in the Twin Ports during the work week for orders placed in advance. No delivery fees!! Call now, 715-394-2500

What are the delivery requirements?

Before we can prepare and deliver our most excellent pizza to your office:

  • » Please place your order (at minimum) 24-hours in advance.
  • » Please have a minimum order of three 16 inch pizzas.
  • » Delivery destination must be a business in Duluth or Superior.
  • » Deliveries will be made only during the work week, 11AM-1PM.

How do I order?

Easy! Take a look at our specialty pizza or custom gourmet pizza then call us at 715-394-2500.

Thirsty Pagan

The old brewery location

Brewery Selections

We have expanded the selection of beer, so there are up 16 different varieties, something for everyone! We feature 7 different house specialties: North Coast Amber, Derailed Ale, Burntwood Black, India Pagan Ale, Lawn Chair, Velo Saison, and Trouble Maker Tripel.

One of the seasonal brews is often found on our hand pump. This wonderful invention allows us to have an English style beverage available at all times. The beers on this tap have a bit more flavor, and are sometimes dry hopped. The hand pump is always served in 20 ounce glasses the way the English do it!

Our seasonal beverages rotate out rather quickly as they are very popular, so, make sure to grab a growler on your way out the door if you find something you like. Because, when you come back for that same awesome seasonal, it may already have been rotated out!

Want to take our beer home with you to share with your friends? Can do! We sell growlers (64 oz and 32 ozcontainers). Even on Sunday. We will also fill other breweries growlers if you bring them in. We aren't fussy, we just want you to enjoy quality beer. Doesn't everyone?

Seasonals and Guest Brew

  • Wild Rice Golden Ale (Guest Brewer Series: Scott Hanson)
  • 5.4% ABV 28 IBU
  • Rosemary IPA
  • 7.8% ABV 62? IBU
  • Mustache Wax
  • 4.6% ABV 43 IBU
  • Limerick Stout (nitro)
  • 5.5% ABV 40 IBU
  • 1/2 Stache Pale SMaSH
  • 5.0% ABV 29 IBU
  • Mariner's Best Bitter
  • 4.8% ABV 35 IBU
  • Kalifornier
  • 5.4% ABV 21 IBU
  • Reinhold Berliner Weisse
  • 5.5% ABV 5 IBU
  • Guest Tap - White Winter Winery: Hard Cider
Thirsty Pagan's Hand Pump

Thirsty Pagan's Hand Pump

Hand Pump

  • Thirsty Pagan Brewing Hand Pump
  • Dark English Mild
Thirsty Pagan Brews

Thirsty Pagan House Specialties

House Specialties

  • North Coast Amber
  • Well balanced Amber Ale. Brewed with Munich and caramel malts.
  • Derailed Ale
  • Classic American Pale Ale. Brewed with Glacier, Colombus, and Cascade hops.
  • Burntwood Black
  • Roasty, malty, Black Ale brewed with seven varieties of barley for complex, robust flavor.
  • India Pagan Ale
  • Our version of a West Coast style IPA, it has a light body with a tropical fruit like finish.
  • Lawn Chair
  • An ale version of a light lager. It is fermented cool and is crisp, clean, and low hopped.
  • Velo Saison
  • Pilsen, wheat and Munich malts set the stage for the yeast's fruity and spicy esters.
  • Trouble Maker Tripel
  • This Belgian Style Tripel may be light in color, but is big in flavor and alcohol.
Thirsty Pagan

Menu

Check out our excellent eats and other treats by selecting a category to the left. Our specialty is pizza, although we offer a fine selection of appetizers in addition to the kid menu

Appetizers

  • TPB Bread | $8.95
  • 10” round of fresh-baked pizza dough topped with olive oil, fresh garlic, cheese & spices. Served with warm pizza sauce for dipping.
  • Stuffed Mushrooms | $9.95
  • Stuffed with garlic, spinach, parmesan, secret herbs & spices, then smothered with mozzarella.
  • Pretzel & Mustard | $2.95
  • Served with our house-made mustard.
  • Garlic Bread | $4.95
  • Made with real olive oil, fresh garlic & cheese.
  • Bohemian Salad | $8.95
  • Fresh spinach, red onions, red pepper, mushrooms, feta, sun-dried tomatoes, black olives & pepperoncini. Served with bread & a side of house vinaigrette or ranch dressing.
  • Side Salad | $3.95
  • Spinach, tomatoes, onions, cheddar & a side of house vinaigrette or ranch dressing.
TPB is Kid Friendly!

Even the kids love Thirsty Pagan!

Kid Menu

  • Mini Pizza | $4.95

  • 6" fresh baked pizza with up to 3 toppings.
  • Mini Sub | $4.95
  • Ham, cheese, spinach & tomato with chips and a pickle spear.
  • Pretzel & Mustard | $2.95
Thirsty Pagan Pizza

Customize Your Own Thirsty Pagan Pizza!

Pizza

Our gourmet pizzas are made to order using the finest meats, fresh cut vegetables, and topped with real Wisconsin cheese. For a dollar more, we'll make you a half n' half pizza!

  10" 13" 16"
Cheese $10.95 $14.95 $19.95
Each Ingredient $1.25 $1.50 $1.75
Ingredients to choose from:
  • Spicy Italian Sausage
  • Pepperoni
  • Ham
  • Salami
  • Pepperoncini
  • Chicken
  • Black Olives
  • Broccoli
  • Feta Cheese
  • Fresh Garlic
  • Green Olives
  • Green Peppers
  • Jalapeños
  • Mushrooms
  • Onions
  • Pineapple
  • Red Onion
  • Red Peppers
  • Spinach
  • Sun dried Tomatoes
  • Tomatoes

Specialty Pizza

  10" 13" 16"
Derailed
Sausage, pepperoni, salami, ham, black olives, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, spinach, garlic & pepperoncini
$14.95 $20.95 $28.95
TPB Special
Spicy Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.
$12.95 $18.95 $25.95
Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers, garlic, spinach & pepperoncini.
$12.95 $18.95 $25.95
Mediterranean Pizza
Feta, spinach, garlic & sun-dried tomatoes.
$12.95 $18.95 $25.95
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Red peppers, broccoli, spinach, chicken breast & homemade Alfredo sauce.
$12.95 $18.95 $25.95
Pizza Diane
Pesto sauce topped with chicken, feta and mozzarella cheese, tomato & spinach.
$14.95 $20.95 $28.95
Calzone
Select any three toppings from the pizza ingredients
$12.95    
Past Thirsty Pagan Specials

Past Thirsty Pagan Specials

TPB Food Specials August 15th to August 28th

  • French Philly Steak Pizza | 10" - $14.95 |13" - $20.95 |16" - $28.95
    Shane has come up with this delicious pizza that tastes like a combo French dip and Philly Steak. Starting with a beef gravy, we add green pepper, mozzarella, roasted red pepper, marinated steak, and green onions. It is a must try!

Recommeded Beer Pairing- Burntwood Black
  • Bruschetta Pizza | 10" - $14.95 |13" - $20.95 |16" - $28.95
    Belle is back at it again! She has come up with the Bruschetta Pizza. Starting off with a brushing of olive oil, we put put on the house-made bruschetta next. Then, add light mozzarella, and parmesan. A delicious, light pizza. ~Recommended Beer Pairing - Derailed Ale

  • Reuben Rollups | $10.95
    This one has been a big hit! Pizza crust stuffed with corned beef, our secret sauce, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese. We roll it all up, bake it, cut it in pieces and serve it with an extra side of sauce. Try this, you will be back for more! ~Recommended Beer Pairing - Lawn Chair

  • Hummus Dip with Chips $6.95
    We have made up a great hummus dip with chickpeas and lots of spices. Top it off with sour cream, cheddar cheese, and chopped tomatoes, and served with a plate of tortilla chips. ~Recommended Beer Pairing -Lawn Chair

Happy Hour

  • Monday-Thursday | 3-6PM
    $3.75 Pints

  • Sunday-Thursday | 3-6PM
    $5.00 TPB Bread Special

    • Margherita - olive oil, garlic, fresh tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella cheese
    • Artichoke and cheese - Artichoke hearts, spinach mayo, parmesan, garlic, and melted mozzarella

Daily Specials

  • Sunday Night |
  • $11 Pitchers from 9-11
  • Monday Night |
  • Late Night Happy Hour 8-Close
  • To-Go Special that includes 2-Topping Medium Pizza and Growler fill for $20
  • Tuesday Night |
  • $6 growler fill with any dine-in pizza

Merch Specials

  • 22 oz. bomber of the Sawmill Sipper $15

Thirsty Pagan Wine Selection

Thirsty Pagan Wine Selection

Wine Selections

  • Little Penguin Merlot | $5.50 Glass
  • Five Rivers Cabernet Sauvignon | $5.50 Glass
  • Cono Sur Pinot Noir | $5.50 Glass
  • Cline Red Zinfandel | $5.50 Glass
  • Mirassou Chardonnay | $5.50 Glass
  • Lagaria Pinot Grigio | $5.50 Glass
  • Redwood Creek White Zinfandel | $5.50 Glass